It is enough.
The verifiable fact that we are star dust is enough. So many religious believers are not satisfied by the simple awe, question, and mystery that envelopes us non-believers who look into the cosmos and see it for what it is: a universe that (as far as we know now) isn't looking back at us; it isn't staring or caring back at us. Since I broke the spell religion had on my life over a decade ago my argument has always been a religious worldview totally robs us of the purity of our sense of awe and wonder at the cosmos.
Compare:
Two scenarios: Two different people are out star gazing in the middle of the Mohave Desert on a perfectly clear night. The Milky Way is crystal clear and the colors of the spiral arms of this galaxy are bright and near blinding in their brilliance. I'm sure we've all experienced some place so free of light pollution that the stars appear so bright they almost hurt your eyes. It always feels like you are in a dream, swimming like an astronaut among the stars flecked among the deep black. It is a very surreal experience. Something our ancient ancestors saw every night.
One of these people looking up is a pastor of a local church. He is staring up at the galaxy and thinking about a Father "out there", somewhere beyond and above the entire universe he created. This Father is outside of his creation looking right back at us with deep love for us. This night, with the galaxy coating all he sees, he is reminded of this Father's Son that is also the father too (with a ghost) that "wrote himself" into the story (his creation) that he began at the Big Bang. This is the story with an extremely long prelude-- where the Father waited patiently while giant reptile-monsters (dinosaurs) ruled for several hundred million years, five major mass extinctions killing altogether some 99% of the life he created on this planet, then several 100,000 years of painful early hominid species suffering/death to lead finally to Genesis and Adam and Eve in the Bible! - all of this to get to this one moment.
The moment of the pastor and his Father.
Beautiful right?
This pastor rejoices in this moment at the confirmation that it is the CREATOR of the universe that cares! This creator cares about our lowly species! How miraculous! This pastor then connects this thought of a Father God that loves him so, who created this universe with him in mind, who created this very moment with his only begotten Son(himself). This god-son that became man (one of his creation) fills this pastor with joy. He becomes overwhelmed with gratitude and peace when he reflects on all that pain and suffering experienced by the Son of God on that ancient cross. Hallelujah!
It wasn't just the torture. Many common criminals and zealots were nailed to this Roman torture device. The pain and suffering was a trillion times over due to the Son of God taking on all human sin! Did this sin-drenched pain and suffering hurt worse than all the living species pain and suffering in all five mass extinctions up until this day? Yes. It REALLY hurt so much! The pastor didn't remember if this was in the Bible but it probably was!
This pastor is reflecting on the cosmos through a Christian worldview. This night sky, this stunning beauty of a color-speckled galaxy full of billions of stars causes this pastor to reflect further on the "rules" of this cosmos. The rules that forced God to send his only begotten Son/himself. "It's all damned. All of it!"- The pastor thought. "It's all going down due to the 'first two humans' in a magical perfect garden." The first two of our species god created specially are the ones who fucked it all up. These first sinners pulled the whole future of the human race (and even somehow the other hominid species of the past) down with them. Yet before all of this, God's favorite angels rebelled against him and were cast out of heaven. The leader of these rebellious angels took the form of a snake in this magical garden to tempt these "first two humans", pulling the overwhelming majority of humans down to hell to burn forever.
All of this the pastor soaks in as tears roll down his face. This is the Christian worldview. You see, this beautiful spiral galaxy on full display above this pastor's head leads this Christian to ponder all of these things: Angels, demons, Satan, a magical garden, miracles, God's Son, a specific ancient Roman torture device, blood atonement, appeasement of a wrathful yet also loving Cosmic Father. This is all tacked on to the null hypothesis (- where the atheist starts its worldview). The Christian knows so much about the cosmos when looking up at it! It's amazing! So the creator of the moon, the sun, the stars, the galaxy does "care back" at stargazing humans! The Father who created it all, behind it all (even guided evolution of species) while also among it all (by his guiding hand in the natural world: prayer works obviously!), does care about our species. He cares so much!... Why?
Well, because dads cares, why wouldn't they?
The second person looking up at the night sky is an atheist. Like the pastor he/she may be very knowledgeable of cosmology and astronomy; he or she may know enough physics to realize physical laws in motion above. This atheist may understand enough about human anatomy to realize the mechanisms of our eye and how the starlight interacts with it. This person may understand the details of the evolution of how eyes evolved and their importance in early species.
This person may be transported back in time when we were fish moving in and out of water for food with our fins, or more accurately described as proto-limbs! This atheist reflects on the giant shells of geologic time that has passed not only above him but on the solid rock that makes up the planet in which he is standing on. Tears roll down the atheist's face as finally he/she realizes the genetic lottery that he/she won to even be here at all! The fact that the atheist is a conscious, big-brained ape that can understand the overwhelming evidence of the evolution of life on his/her home planet is mind-boggling. To the atheist this one life is all we most likely have. There is no evidence of afterlives. The atheist realizes in this very profound moment of awe and wonder while basking in the night sky that this very moment is all there is and time is somewhat of a puzzling substance.
However, time has gotten the best of both of these two stargazers. The pastor and the atheist both, separately get into their vehicles and drive home, back to the light pollution cities they call home. They both go back to their loved ones, their friends and family. They both enjoy the social pleasures and friendships that create a meaning that is local while the cosmos exists above - cold, indifferent (as if it makes sense to attribute these attributes to an attribute-less entity)
These two stargazers: The atheist and the theist looking up at the night sky are ultimately robbing themselves in the end because they eventually are thinking about how the other one is thinking about the cosmos. The atheist is laughing and shaking his head at the childishness, archaic absurdity of the Christian worldview of the cosmos while the theist is wondering how the atheist can be a nihilist and still be filled with equal awe and wonder. If there is no creator then creation is meaningless - despite what the atheist says. Maybe one day we can fight the notion of being so dogmatic all we think about is worldviews and how they are wrong or right. As Carl Sagan said we should be delighted in the profound fact that a part of the cosmos (those species that are sentient and can contemplate the cosmos) has become aware and able to know itself. This is enough. No mythical creatures or gods required to make this powerful. It just is and that is all.
for now.